Suppose you woke up one day and found yourself attached by tubes to another person, and then you are told that this other person will die if you disconnect the tubes. You, however, will not be injured. Supposed…
I love how such a ridiculous hypothetical situation that can never and will never happen is being compared to a common procedure that tens of millions of women around the world have, whether it’s legal, illegal, safe, or unsafe. Whether or not their lives and the lives of their families depend on it. To the OP, all I have to say is fuck you. Seriously. Fuck. You. Unwanted pregnancy is a serious issue to everyone who faces it. Listen to the stories of the people who seek the procedure and are hell-bent of getting an abortion, rather than making up some convoluted bullshit that nobody will ever experience to rationalize your misogynistic views.
Sigh. Another case of someone jumping to conclusions. I, the OP, am VERY pro-choice. I made this post with the intent of showing that, even under these circumstances, it should be FULLY within the rights of the person in this situation to pull the tubes. Perhaps my more exact analogy would be more to your liking?
Peace,
~ Steve
What would be more to my liking would be for cis guys to stop turning a discussion of abortion rights into a philosophical discussion of hypotheticals. I don’t have to jump to the conclusion of your male privilege denial.
Well, fortunately, I don’t have to respect your opinion on how I should go about supporting your rights. And I also don’t have to respect your jumping to the conclusion that I’m cis. Or that I deny white male privilege.
~ Steve
You denied your male privilege twice in the past five minutes. Maybe you should consider the opinions of the people your pro-choice views affect, if you’re going to consider yourself a pro-choice advocate. Just some advice that you’d be wise to take.
…I’d like to understand how trying to make a point that would essentially help change or alter the minds of the people fighting against pro-choice is in any way harmful. This in-fighting is very counter productive.
I totally agree. Guys, chill out! This is a great example why the pro-choice, feminist, liberal, agnostic, skeptic, and atheist community, and free thinkers in general, are having trouble passing legislations and getting things done. Why are we constantly at each other’s throats for stupid little details? White male privilege? Really?
The bottom line here is that we are all PRO-CHOICE. I may not agree with analogy that the OP made, my reasons for being pro-choice may be different than yours, my gender, race, age, and color of skin may be different than yours, so what? And then we’re asking ourselves why the pro-life, conservative community is on the rise; well, because they are organized and have each other’s back, while we, as Dawkins puts it, are like a bunch of individualist, ego-centric cats that cannot be herded (no offense to cats).
Just take it down a notch. Peace!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Oe6HUgrRlQ&feature=player_embedded
151 notes (via marmoulak & religiousragings)
Hypothetical situations could happen. This guy went well beyond posing a hypothetical situation and just threw out a...
Now try thinking from...directly associated with...couldn’t...
Well, me for one. I’ve read a lot of hypothetical situations and participated in thought experiments that lead me to...
He tried. He failed. He didn’t offer criticism of this ridiculous situation. He just threw it out there to start a...
Feminists putting their foot in their mouths, again.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Oe6HUgrRlQ&feature=player_embedded
I totally agree. Guys, chill out! This is a great example why the pro-choice, feminist, liberal, agnostic, skeptic, and...
It’s amazing to me how many people don’t realize that two people can have the same thought. I’ve come up with plenty of...
Reblogging for the last comment.
let somebody else die. I’d...absolutely could...illegal for...
Let me toss something in here as a fellow pro-choice feminist. If you were REALLY about equality, you would NEVER drag...
LOL! Did it ever occur to you that two people could come up with similar examples WITHOUT stealing from each other. My...
THE OP STOLE THIS THOUGHT EXPERIMENT! THE OP STOLE THIS THOUGHT EXPERIMENT! THE OP STOLE THIS THOUGHT EXPERIMENT! No,...
This is to prove that even if the fetus was sentient, it would still have no right to live off of someone else, and no...
Worthy of the read.
No, it’s not. Jesus fucking christ. OP is showing how no one has the right to your body, EVER. That was VERY easy to...
…I’d like to understand how trying to make a point that would essentially help change or alter the minds of the people...
Well, yeah, it is pretty shitty. People should just get it. People should have some empathy and actually listen to...